How to choose a UGC agency: 7 questions to ask before you hire
To choose a UGC agency, looking at the videos on its homepage is not enough. Everyone shows their best work. What separates an agency that takes work off your plate from one that adds to it is how it operates: who picks the creators, who writes, what happens when a video misses, and what you are allowed to do with it afterwards. These are the seven questions we would ask if we were on the other side.
1. Who picks the creators, and how?
The answer you want is “by niche and by how they come across on camera.” If the agency leads with follower counts, it is thinking about influencers, not UGC. With UGC the video runs in your ads or on your channels, not on the creator’s account, so followers barely matter. What matters is whether the person is believable using your product.
Ask to see profiles before anyone shoots. A serious agency shows you options and lets you choose. At AG we work with 70+ core creators and a casting pool of 2,000+, and you see the profiles before the shoot. What to look for in each one is in how to choose the right UGC creator.
2. Who writes the script?
Some agencies only source creators and leave the script to you or to the creator. That works if you already have a team writing for paid social. If not, you usually end up with a tidy video that does not sell. Ask whether the script is included, whether you approve it before the shoot, and whether it comes with alternative openings to test. The first seconds decide whether someone stays, and they should be planned before the camera is on. Our piece on scripts for UGC and ads covers what a good one needs.
3. How many revisions are included, and what counts as one?
This is where most misunderstandings start. Trimming a section, fixing a subtitle or moving the music is an edit. Reshooting is something else. Ask for it in writing: how many revisions each video includes and what happens if you later want a new take. With us, every video includes one revision.
4. Which usage rights come with the video?
This is the question that saves you the most trouble. A video you can post on your Instagram is not the same as a video you can run as an ad for six months in three countries. The license has to be in writing and spell out channels, countries and duration. If the agency does not bring it up, ask before you pay. The details are in UGC usage rights.
5. How long does it take, and when does the clock start?
“We deliver in a week” can mean a lot of things. Ask when the clock actually starts. It makes sense for it to start once the creator has the product and the script is approved, because nobody can shoot before that. We deliver within 7 business days from that point.
6. Can they show work from your industry?
They do not need to have worked with your competitors, but they should show you videos for something similar. Selling a finance app is nothing like selling yogurt: the kind of creator, the tone and what needs explaining all change. Ask for real examples with the brand visible. Our full portfolio has 55 videos, and we have pages by industry: fintech, beauty, food and beverage, tech and four more.
7. What does the price include, and in which currency do they bill?
Ask what the quote covers: script, casting, shoot, editing, rights and revisions. Two numbers that look the same may not be if one of them charges rights or editing separately. If your brand is outside Argentina, also ask which currency they invoice in. We quote case by case, small trial packs included, and bill in ARS, USD or EUR.
Three red flags
They will not let you see the creators before the shoot. Nothing about rights is in writing. And they promise a sales figure before they know your product. A good video helps you sell, but no serious agency guarantees a result before testing.
If you want something concrete to compare against, tell us what you need in the quote form and we will reply within 24 business hours. That gives you a real proposal to measure the others against.